Background noise in video interviews can be a double-edged sword. In some cases, it can add depth and context to the content, while in others, it can be distracting or detrimental. As a freelance filmmaker, I always strive to find the quietest location possible, as it's easier to add background noise in post-production than remove it. In this article, we'll discuss when background noise can be acceptable and even beneficial, and when it can be counterproductive to the goals of the interview.
Finding the Right Balance: As a filmmaker, I have equipment and techniques at my disposal to not only hide microphones and keep them out of the shot but also to minimize background noise. However, there are times when incorporating background noise can enhance the overall experience. It's crucial to strike the right balance and consider the impact of background noise on your video interview.
When Background Noise Works:
Lots of “moooo’s” were captured with this interview.
Relevance and visibility: Background noise can be acceptable if it's relevant to the subject matter and the source of the noise can be seen in the interview. For example, interviewing a school principal with children playing in the background, or discussing city life with traffic noise and visuals of passing cars. This helps the viewer understand the context of the interview and adds authenticity to the content.
Atmosphere: As mentioned earlier, background noise can help create a specific atmosphere or mood in the video. For example, the chatter and clinking of cups in a busy coffee shop can create a more relaxed and informal vibe.
Storytelling: Background noise can contribute to the narrative of the video by providing additional context and setting. For instance, interviewing a musician at a concert venue with soundcheck or crowd noise in the background can enhance the viewer's understanding of the interview's context.
When Background Noise Can Be Distracting or Detrimental:
Clarity: If the background noise is too loud or intrusive, it can make it difficult for the viewer to hear and understand the interviewee's responses. In such cases, it's best to minimize background noise to ensure clear communication.
Focus: Excessive or irrelevant background noise can divert the viewer's attention away from the main subject, making it harder for them to engage with the content.
Professionalism: In certain settings, such as corporate interviews or formal presentations, background noise might be perceived as unprofessional or indicative of poor planning.
Editing Challenges: Background noise can make editing sound bites more difficult, as the noise may change between cuts, affecting the overall flow and consistency of the video.
So, background noise in a video interview can be acceptable and even beneficial, depending on the context, atmosphere, and storytelling goals. However, it's essential to strike the right balance and utilize appropriate equipment and techniques to ensure that the noise enhances the video rather than detracting from it. Always consider the relevance, visibility, and impact of the background noise on your video interview to make the best decision for your project.